Supreme Court leaves Maryland’s sensitive-place gun ruling in place
The Court declined to review a broad challenge to Maryland’s restrictions. Justice Clarence Thomas suggested taking up a narrower case in the future.
The Supreme Court declined on Nov. 16 to review a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland restrictions on carrying guns in designated places. The order in Novotny v. Moore leaves intact a Fourth Circuit ruling that upheld the provisions challenged in this petition. Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the decision to deny review and wrote separately about a question he would consider in a different case.
The challenged restrictions cover several kinds of places, including mass transit, health care facilities, places that sell alcohol for on-site consumption, and portions of state parks and forest land. The Fourth Circuit treated the challenged locations as sensitive places. That idea matters under the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision, which directs courts to consider whether firearm regulations are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of regulation.
Thomas wrote that the breadth of the petition complicated review because different locations call for different historical comparisons. He expressed skepticism that every restriction fit that tradition and said a more focused case could be a better vehicle for deciding where states have authority to limit public carry.
A denial of review leaves the lower court ruling standing without resolving the constitutional merits in a new Supreme Court opinion. Thomas’s statement is the view of one justice, and neither the denial nor his statement guarantees that a narrower appeal will reach the Court.