Lisboa and Virginia Pepsi Bottler Settled Federal Suit. A Later Order Went to Appeal.
The Virginia labor suit ended in a February settlement whose financial terms are undisclosed in the court materials reviewed. A later refusal to reopen the case went to the Fourth Circuit.
Editorial disclosure The person who commissioned this series also directs work on the Toy Soldier Central website. Paulo Lisboa, who does business as Toy Soldier Central, is a party to the four cases in this series.
Paulo Lisboa and the defendants settled a federal labor dispute involving Pepsi-Cola Bottling Company of Central Virginia at a February 12, 2026 conference, according to the Eastern District of Virginia’s docket. On February 27, District Judge Leonie M. Brinkema dismissed the case with prejudice. The public court materials reviewed by Tricycle Media USA do not disclose the settlement’s financial terms.
Pepsi-Cola Bottling Company of Central Virginia moved the suit from Prince William County Circuit Court to federal court on June 27, 2025. In his July 11 amended complaint, Lisboa alleged that he was improperly classified as an independent contractor and denied overtime, and argued that PV Enterprises Inc. and the bottling company shared employer responsibilities. The complaint also asserted Virginia wage-payment and other civil claims, with Patrick A. Voit and Tom Matthews named as defendants. The named bottler was the Central Virginia company. PepsiCo Inc. does not appear as a party on the district docket.
The bottler and Matthews moved to dismiss in August. Their brief argued that the complaint failed to show they had a role in the classification decision or that either qualified as Lisboa’s employer. PV Enterprises and Voit filed separate dismissal motions, and Lisboa opposed the motions. The district docket classifies the dispute under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act. The parties’ filings put worker classification, overtime and joint employer responsibility in issue.
Magistrate Judge Ivan D. Davis oversaw the settlement conference. The minute entry describes an eight-hour session with all parties present and records that they reached a settlement. On February 27, the bottler and Matthews filed a stipulation of dismissal and a joint request for a final order. A separate related filing appears on the docket under seal. Brinkema signed the final order the same day, ending the action with prejudice and disposing of pending motions as moot. A dismissal with prejudice generally bars litigating the same claims again. The order records the disposition of the case without deciding the disputed factual allegations.
Lisboa later asked the district court to reopen the case under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(3) and filed a separate motion for sanctions. Brinkema denied both requests in an order signed July 22 and entered July 23. Lisboa filed a notice of appeal on August 14 identifying that order. The Fourth Circuit docketed the appeal on August 17 as No. 26-2120. The bottler and Matthews filed a response brief on September 9, and Lisboa filed a reply on September 19. The October 15 appellate docket report reviewed for this story shows the briefing and contains no decision. The article therefore reports the settlement and dismissal as district court events, with a separate appellate challenge to the later order.
There is also a separate bankruptcy-court proceeding involving one of the original defendants. The Eastern District of Virginia bankruptcy court’s November 4 calendar listed an initial pretrial conference in Lisboa v. Voit, No. 26-03039-BFK, an adversary proceeding linked to Voit’s Chapter 7 case. The listing identifies a complaint and Voit’s answer. It establishes a separate proceeding and a scheduled conference, without recording a ruling on either the bankruptcy dispute or the status of the district court settlement.
Spokes & Sources
- Eastern District of Virginia docket (PACER): complaint ECF 16, defense brief ECF 30, settlement minute entry, and orders ECF 66 and ECF 73
- Fourth Circuit case summary and docket (PACER), No. 26-2120
- District court public docket mirror (through December 19, 2025)
- Fourth Circuit public docket mirror (through September 19, 2026)
- U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, November 4 calendar, page 11
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, including Rule 60